A $20 Million Mistake: A Startup's Finance Hiring Journey
It's 2 AM, and Sarah, the CEO of a promising SaaS healthtech, is hunched over her laptop, drowning in spreadsheets. Her company just hit $5 million in ARR, but instead of celebrating, she's pulling an all-nighter trying to make sense of their finances.
Why? Because Sarah made a classic startup mistake: she waited too long to hire a finance leader.
The Early Days: Bootstrapping and Spreadsheets
Let's rewind a bit. When Sarah launched her startup three years ago, finances were simple. She and her co-founder split the tasks:
She handled product and sales
He managed the books using a basic spreadsheet
It worked... until it didn't.
The Tipping Point: Series A and Growing Pains
Fast forward to their Series A round. They raised $5 million, and suddenly, things got complicated:
Investor reporting became a monthly headache
Financial projections were more guess than strategy
Tax implications? Don't even ask.
Sarah thought, "We're not big enough for a CFO yet. We'll manage."
Spoiler alert: They didn't.
The $20 Million Wake-Up Call
One year post Series A, disaster struck. Sarah was preparing for their Series B raise when she discovered a $20 million mistake in their financial projections. The root cause? A simple spreadsheet error that had snowballed over months.
Investors were furious. The board was in panic mode. Sarah? She was kicking herself for not hiring a finance leader sooner.
The Turnaround: Enter the VP of Finance
In crisis mode, Sarah fast-tracked hiring a VP of Finance with our team. We were able to present Mike, a seasoned finance pro with startup experience.
Within three months, Mike:
Implemented proper financial systems
Corrected the projections
Established clear financial KPIs
Prepared a revised pitch deck for investors
The result? They secured their Series B funding, albeit delayed and at a lower valuation than originally hoped.
Lessons Learned: When to Hire Finance Leadership
Sarah's story isn't unique. Many founders struggle with the "when" of hiring senior finance roles. Here's what Sarah wished she knew earlier:
Seed Stage: It's okay to outsource or use basic tools. But start planning for finance leadership.
Series A or $5M ARR: This is your trigger. Hire a Director of Finance or VP of Finance. Don't wait.
$10M-$25M ARR: If you haven't already, it's CFO time. You're playing in the big leagues now.
Warning Signs:
You're spending more time on financials than strategy
Investors are asking questions you struggle to answer
You're planning for significant growth or fundraising
A good finance leader doesn't just manage money.
They're a strategic partner who can help you make better decisions and avoid costly mistakes.
The Plot Twist: It's Not Just About Revenue
Here's the kicker: It's not just about hitting a certain revenue number. Consider hiring earlier if:
Your business model is complex
You're in a highly regulated industry
You're growing extremely fast
You're planning an exit or IPO in the next 18-24 months
The Happy Ending
Two years after hiring Mike, Sarah's company is thriving. They're at $50M ARR, preparing for an IPO, and Sarah? She's back to doing what she does best – building an amazing product and closing big deals.
The $20 million mistake? It's a story she now shares with other founders as a cautionary tale.
Don't Repeat Sarah's Mistake
I encourage you to ask yourself:
Are you still doing your own financial modeling?
Is your "finance team" just you and a bookkeeper?
Are you losing sleep over cash flow projections?
If you answered yes to any of these, it might be time to level up your finance game.
Remember, it's not just about how fast you can grow. It's about building a foundation that can support that growth.
And a strong finance leader? They're the architect of that foundation.
Don't wait for your own $20 million wake-up call. Start planning your financial foundation today.
Contact us to create your exclusive VP of Finance hiring strategy
Connect with us on LinkedIn and Instagram
Explore the advantages and disadvantages of using third-party recruiting agencies versus internal hiring resources for senior-level tech, finance, and marketing roles in SMBs and startups. Make informed decisions to optimize your recruitment strategy.